Blog – Insights and Inspiration

The Psychology of Why We Love True Crime

January 12, 2026

3 minute read

It's a peculiar modern phenomenon: we spend our leisure time listening to podcasts about cold cases, binging documentaries about serial killers, and reading the grisly details of the world's most horrific crimes. For many, true crime is the ultimate "comfort media." While it seems contradictory to find relaxation in the macabre, our fascination with the "dark side" is deeply rooted in our evolutionary biology and psychological architecture. We aren't drawn to true crime because we are morbid; we are drawn to it because our brains are designed to pay the closest attention to the things that can kill us. The primary driver of this obsession is Threat Simulation Theory. From an evolutionary standpoint, those who studied the "predator" were the ones most likely to survive. By consuming true crime, we are engaging in a low-stakes "rehearsal" for danger. Our brains treat these stories as a survival manual, teaching us how to spot "red flags," how to avoid dangerous situations, and what to do if the unthinkable happens. This is particularly true for women, who make up the largest demographic of true crime fans. For a group that is statistically more likely to be victims of certain crimes, these stories provide a sense of vicarious agency—a way to study the enemy from a safe distance.

The Psychology of Why We Love True Crime

Another factor is the Search for the "Why." As humans, we have a fundamental need for a predictable world. When a random act of violence occurs, it shatters our "Assumptive World"—the belief that life makes sense and that good things happen to good people. True crime provides a narrative structure that tries to restore that sense of order. By digging into the psychology of the perpetrator—their childhood, their triggers, their "motive"—we attempt to make the irrational rational. If we can find a reason why someone did something, we can convince ourselves that we can predict and prevent it. We are trying to turn a monster back into a man, because a man is something we can understand.

The Psychology of Why We Are Obsessed with "The End of the World"

June 10, 2025

There is also a powerful Neurochemical Component. When we watch or listen to true crime, our bodies go through a controlled "fear cycle." The suspense triggers a release of adrenaline and cortisol (the stress response), but because we know we are safe in our living rooms, the brain follows this up with a "dopamine dump" once the mystery is solved or the episode ends. This "arousal transfer" creates a feeling of intense relief and satisfaction. We are essentially using the darkness of the world to trigger a biological "reset" of our own anxiety. It is a form of Benign Masochism—enjoying a negative experience because we know it has no real-world consequences.

Finally, true crime serves as a Moral Calibration Tool. These stories allow us to explore the extremes of human behavior from a safe moral distance. By witnessing the worst of humanity, we reinforce our own values and social bonds. There is a "cathartic relief" in seeing justice served (or even in the collective outrage when it isn't). It reminds us of the social contract we all live by and validates our own "goodness" by contrast. We are looking into the abyss not to join it, but to remind ourselves exactly where the edge is.

Ultimately, our love for true crime is a testament to our resilience. It is the way our minds process the reality of evil without being consumed by it. We watch, we listen, and we learn, not because we want to live in fear, but because we want to live in the light of understanding. By studying the shadows, we feel better equipped to navigate the world with our eyes wide open, finding a strange kind of peace in the knowledge that even in the face of the inexplicable, we are still here, still watching, and still searching for the truth.